(Note: If you are just joining the seminar, please start by reading the Introduction)
Note: This assignment is due in 2 weeks, with your responses due by the evening of Thursday, December 4th. The next assignment should be posted on Friday, December 5th.
I wonder how much of the differences between Graham’s and Fisher’s styles was due to their personality vs. the environment that shaped them as investors. Recall that Graham started before the Great Depression and the Crash of 1929, and his cautious approach was heavily influenced by that experience. Fisher, on the other hand, came into his prime after World War 2, amid a recovering economy and a new optimism that emerged in the 1950s.
One important thing to understand is that in a way there is far more that the two investors have in common than what separates them. Both are intrinsic value investors who think about buying a stock as a partial ownership stake in a business. That is very different than the speculators of various stripes who mostly care what someone else will pay regardless of value.
Beyond that, the two investors had major differences. Fisher was all about the qualitative, with management a key factor in his approach. He was looking for exceptional outlier companies that could defy the forces of economic gravity for decades to come.
Graham, on the other hand, was looking for margin of safety in terms of current assets or a past earnings record supported by a resilient business. His posture was to guard against future developments since all he required was reversion to the company’s prior earnings mean to make his return.
The two investors, Graham and Fisher, define the continuum of intelligent long-term investing. Most other successful approaches that I have encountered have elements of both of these two great investors’ processes.
In response to Question 1 Tibor V wrote:
Similarities:
- Concentrated portfolios;
- Importance of fundamental analysis, both qualitative and quantitative analysis;
- Importance of relating the earnings to average capital employed in business;
- Taking into consideration the impact on the price (multiple/PE) of a given issue, the appraisal of the financial community, mass physiology and Mr. Market;
- To increase the probability of success hard work and diligence are necessary. 2H and 1I approach: “Success depends on Hard work, intelligence, honesty”.
Differences:
- Quality and growth potential at Fisher over value, bargain and protection at Graham;
- Willingness to pay higher prices, multiple for a given issue at Fischer;
- More focus on qualitative factors at Fischer;
- Importance of scuttlebutt approach at Fischer and lack of it at Graham;
- Necessity to talk to management at Fischer;
- Longer holding period, more “forever “time horizon at Fischer vs Graham’s shorter ones, except for Graham’s investment in Geico;
- More quantitative rules for selling at Graham;
- Type of companies, sectors covered, mentioned, invested in: Technology (Semi-conductor), Communication at Fisher vs Industrials, Railways at Graham (Nb. Based on the second edition of SA);
- Significant importance and easier determination of margin of safety at Graham;
- No word about intrinsic value by Fischer;
- More discuss and detail about specific valuation and quantitative metrics at Graham.
In response to Question 2 Andrei Tonkikh wrote:
What I would take from Graham and Fisher
From both: skepticism toward forecasts and market fads.
From Graham: discipline, objectivity, and reproducibility of analysis. An investment decision should not depend on the analyst’s mood, and its reasoning should be clear enough to reconstruct and verify honestly even a year later.
From Fisher: attention to the long-term development of a business. However, I prefer a quantitative approach. Fisher rightly points out that financial results are driven by business quality, management, and the decisions they make. But directly assessing these factors inevitably involves a considerable degree of subjectivity.
My approach is based on the idea that the quality of a business and its management should be reflected in its financial results, above all in how those results change over time. Numbers do not always explain the reasons for success, but they allow us to assess its actual manifestations objectively.
That is why I prefer not to forecast a company’s future achievements or make subjective judgments about its management, but instead to analyze financial patterns that have already been observed, using consistent, predefined rules.
The lag between changes in business quality and their appearance in financial indicators is not critical to me. Major long-term stock-price movements are shaped to a significant extent by institutional investors, who need time to build or adjust large positions. As a result, a substantial interval may remain between the emergence of confirmed financial trends and their full reflection in long-term price movements. I am not talking about short-term market reactions to earnings releases. This is precisely why financial dynamics, despite their apparent lag, can still provide a timely and verifiable investment signal.
In response to Question 5 Lattice Notes wrote:
Fisher provides a comprehensive way of analyzing the quality of a business, its management, and long-term earning potential. I find there’s a significant emphasis on evaluating management. While I agree with the importance of strong management, I think there are two things to consider.
Some of the criteria can be in tension with each other, making it difficult to determine how much emphasis should be placed on one versus another. For example, Amazon’s early strategy of investing in wider product selection, lower prices, and faster delivery came at the expense of short-term profitability. Amazon reported significant losses in its early years and later introduced Prime with free two-day shipping in 2005. These investments helped develop customer loyalty and became important competitive advantages. This creates a tension between Fisher’s criteria #5 and #6, which emphasize profitability and margins, and criterion #12, which emphasizes long-term profits. How should an investor assess whether sacrificing current profitability will actually lead to greater long-term value?
It is not always easy to assess management correctly, especially in organizations that are innovating. For example, management may be making significant investments in an unproven technology that an investor, based on their research, believes is a mistake. However, management’s decisions may simply be misunderstood in the short term. Amazon’s investments in AWS are a good example. The company faced skepticism about its investment in cloud computing, which ultimately proved to be a successful long-term decision.
Week 5 assignment is to read Buffett’s Partnership Letters (not to be confused with the Berkshire Hathaway letters, those are next). If you search for “Buffett Partnership Letters” in your favorite search engine, you should be able to find them, let me know if you have any issues. Please answer the following questions:
Question 1: What were the three different investment types that Buffett invested in? What do you think about each one?
Question 2: What of what Buffett described would be not possible or be less effective today? Why?
Question 3: What changes have you observed in Buffett’s approach from the earlier days of when he began managing the partnership as compared to the later partnership years?
Question 4: What do you think of Buffett’s decision to return funds to investors? What would have been other alternatives and the pros/cons of each?
Question 5: What was your favorite investment that Buffett made during the partnership days? What made it your favorite?
Question 6: What was your least favorite investment that Buffett made during the partnership days. What made it your least favorite?
Question 7: How did Buffett approach constructing his portfolio and managing risk? What do you like/not like about his approach?
Question 8: Map the Buffett from the partnership letters on as many dimensions of an investment style as you can think of. An example of a dimension: long-term vs. short-term, quantitative vs. qualitative, deep vs. shallow research, etc.
Question 9: Come up with an AI prompt based on Warren Buffett’s Partnership-days approach.
Now it’s your turn:
Submit your answers in the comments below this article with all your answers in a single comment. I will engage with some of the answers each week and highlight some of the ones I find most insightful in next week’s seminar assignment article. Please submit your answers by the evening of Thursday, December 4th.
Engage with the answers of some of your fellow seminar members in the comments below. Remember – the goal is to learn together. Be kind, be respectful and try to add to our learning as a community.
Feel free to ask any questions about the reading in your comment.
Until two weeks from now,
Gary
About the author

Gary Mishuris, CFA is the Managing Partner and Chief Investment Officer of Silver Ring Value Partners, an investment firm that seeks to apply its intrinsic value approach to safely compound capital over the long-term. He also teaches the Value Investing Seminar at the F.W. Olin Graduate School of Business.



